Ensuing Loss Provision Salvages Coverage for Water Damage Claim
September 16, 2024 —
Tred R. Eyerly - Insurance Law HawaiiThe Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit reversed the district court's finding of no coverage and found that the ensuing loss provision provided coverage for water damage. 3524 East Cap Venture, LLC, et al. v. Weschester Fire Ins. Co., et al., 104 F. 4th 193 (D.C. Cir. 2024).
Plaintiff 3534 East Cap Venture, LLC, a real-estate developer, hired plaintiff McCullough Construction, LLC, to build a residential and retail complex. Defendants Westchester Fire Insurance Company and Endurance American Insurance Company issued identical builders' risk policies, which covered the building while it was under construction. Each insurer was responsible for half of any qualifying losses.
The policies covered loss caused by or resulting from water damage. The policies, however, excluded loss caused by "dampness of atmosphere" or by "[e]xtremes or changes in temperature." But the exclusions contained an exception if "loss by an insured peril ensues."
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Tred R. Eyerly, Damon Key Leong Kupchak HastertMr. Eyerly may be contacted at
te@hawaiilawyer.com
Traub Lieberman Attorneys Recognized in the 2025 Edition of The Best Lawyers in America®
September 09, 2024 —
Traub LiebermanTraub Lieberman is pleased to announce that five Partners have been selected by their peers for inclusion in the 2025 edition of The Best Lawyers in America®. In addition, seven attorneys have been included in the 2025 Best Lawyers®: Ones to Watch list. These recognitions include attorneys from the firm’s Hawthorne, NY; Chicago, IL; Palm Beach Gardens, FL; and St. Petersburg, FL offices.
2025 Best Lawyers®
Hawthorne, NY
- Lisa L. Shrewsberry – Commercial Litigation
Chicago, IL
- Brian C. Bassett – Insurance Law
Palm Beach Gardens, FL
- Rina Clemens – Personal Injury Litigation – Defendants, Product Liability Litigation – Defendants
St. Petersburg, FL
- Lauren S. Curtis – Insurance Law
- Scot E. Samis – Appellate Practice
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Traub Lieberman
Real Estate & Construction News Roundup (7/10/24) – Strong Construction Investment in Data Centers, Increase Use of Proptech in Hospitality and Effects of Remote-Work on Housing Market
August 05, 2024 —
Pillsbury's Construction & Real Estate Law Team - Gravel2Gavel Construction & Real Estate Law BlogIn our latest roundup, renters stay in their units longer, GenAI change how commercial real estate operates, and banks continue high exposure due to commercial real estate.
- Strong investor interest, particularly in opportunistic and value-add segments, signals a strong market for construction firms specializing in high-yield projects. (Sebastian Obando, Construction Dive)
- A growing number of renters are staying in their units for longer periods of time than they did a decade ago with over one-third of U.S. renters have lived in the same apartment for more than five years. (Mary Salmonsen, Multifamily Dive)
- Several U.S. regional and mid-sized banks continue to face the squeeze from high exposure to the commercial real estate sector that has been shaken by higher-for-longer interest rates and empty office buildings. (Reuters)
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Pillsbury's Construction & Real Estate Law Team
You Cannot Always Contract Your Way Out of a Problem (The Case for Dispute Resolution in Mega and Large Complex Construction Projects)
September 16, 2024 —
Lisa D. Love - The Dispute ResolverMost experienced commercial transaction and construction attorneys strive to negotiate a concisely written and well-drafted contract that addresses all scenarios and issues that creative and highly contemplative professionals can conjure. Although contracts are extremely important in construction projects, “you can’t generally contract your way out of a problem,” states Michael Loulakis, a founder of Capital Project Strategies, LLC and a nationally recognized expert on project delivery systems in complex public sector design-build projects and public-private partnership programs. Loulakis adds, “the contract certainly matters. But particularly when the losses are big, litigators prosecuting the contractors often find effective ways to argue that facts and circumstances trump the contract.” However, “the difference between the best construction projects and the worst construction projects is not the written words of the contracts but how the parties have committed to engage collaboratively and with trust to complete the project,” notes Robynn Thaxton, an attorney and consultant with Thaxton Parkinson PLLC and Progressive Design-Build Consulting, LLC and one of the leading experts in construction law and alternative procurement on a national basis.[i]
In large, complex construction projects, the need for parties to collaboratively resolve disputes is highlighted by the judicial acceptance of the “Doctrine of the Contextual Contract”[ii] to interpret construction contracts. “As construction’s increasing technological and managerial complexity came to be recognized, some common law courts began turning away from strict interpretation of language within the four corners of a contract and moving toward recognizing in the enforcement of contracts the construction industry’s own experience, customs, practices and implied conditions and duties and the factual context underlying the contract. Courts [began the journey] along the road from ‘text’ to ‘context.’”[iii] Thus, the precise wording of the contract has become less important and industry practices and other conditions provide insight for resolving disputes. Consequently, despite the specific language of any construction contract and the clear allocation of responsibilities and risks, early dispute evaluation and resolution are critical to a successful project.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Lisa D. Love, JAMS
Understanding Insurance Disputes in Construction Defect Litigation: A Review of Acuity v. Kinsale
December 17, 2024 —
David M. McLain – Colorado Construction Litigation BlogConstruction projects are inherently complex, and insurance coverage plays a crucial role in managing risks, especially when unforeseen issues arise. The case of Acuity v. Kinsale demonstrates the tangled web of insurance obligations, especially when multiple insurers provide coverage for a single event. This case, involving Monarch Stucco, Inc., Acuity, and Kinsale Insurance Company, sheds light on the challenges that contractors, subcontractors, and insurers may face when disputes over liability and coverage occur.
The Background of the Case
At the heart of this dispute lies a construction defect at a retirement community project in Lakewood, Colorado. Monarch Stucco, Inc. (“Monarch”), a subcontractor hired by GH Phipps Construction Company (“Phipps”), was responsible for stucco work on the project. Unfortunately, defects in the building’s envelope system, particularly Monarch’s stucco work, led to significant damage and costly repairs.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
David M. McLain, Higgins, Hopkins, McLain & Roswell, LLCMr. McLain may be contacted at
mclain@hhmrlaw.com
Changes to Judicial Selection in Mexico Create a New Case for Contractual ADR Provisions
November 25, 2024 —
Juan Pablo Sandoval - The Dispute ResolverThe Mexican Congress recently discussed and approved a Constitutional Amendment called the “Judiciary Amendment” which was ironically published in the Official Gazette on September 15, 2024, the day before Mexican Independence Day.
With this Judiciary Amendment, the Mexican Congress determined that Federal Judges, Federal Magisters and the Ministers of the Supreme Court will now be elected through direct and popular election. Before the Judiciary Amendment, Federal Judges and Magisters used to have a judicial career; many of them started as law clerks and were promoted step by step until becoming Judge or Magister.
Ministers of the Supreme Court were appointed by the Senate through an election of three candidates designated by the President.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Juan Pablo Sandoval, COMAD, S.C.Mr. Sandoval may be contacted at
jpsandoval@comad.com.mx
Hawaiian Electric Finalizes $2 Billion Maui Fire Settlement
November 18, 2024 —
Mark Chediak - BloombergHawaiian Electric Industries formalized a $2 billion agreement to settle damage claims from a wildfire that razed the historic town of Lahaina and killed more than 100 people.
The utility-owner had reached a tentative agreement in August in which it, along with other defendants including the state of Hawaii, Maui County and landowners, would pay $4 billion to resolve hundreds of lawsuits stemming from last year’s wildfire, according to a filing Tuesday.
The settlements don’t resolve claims with insurers that are part of separate lawsuits.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Be a Good Neighbor: Protect Against Claims by an Adjacent Landowner During ConstructionHawaii Appellate Court Finds Appraisers Limited to Determining Amount of LossSchool System Settles Design Defect Suit for $5.2MillionGeneral Liability Alert: ADA Requirements Pertaining to Wall Space Adjacent to Interior Doors ClarifiedArbitration is Waivable (Even If You Don’t Mean To)Henderson Land to Spend $839 Million on Hong Kong Retail ComplexContractor Definition Central to Coverage DisputeConflict of Interest Accusations may Spark Lawsuit Against City and City ManagerWhat is a “Force Majeure” Clause? Do I Need one in my Contract? Three Options For Contractors, Subcontractors and Suppliers to ConsiderWhat California’s COVID-19 Reopening Means for the Construction Industry Got Licensing Questions? CSLB Licensing Workshop November 17th and December 15thThe Colorado Supreme Court holds that loans made to a construction company are not subject to the Mechanic’s Lien Trust Fund StatuteNew Case Law Alert: Licensed General Contractors Cannot Sue Owners to Recover Funds for Work Performed by An Unlicensed SubcontractorCreate a Culture of Safety to Improve Labor Recruitment EffortsMeet the Forum's In-House Counsel: J. PAUL ALLENNine ACS Lawyers Recognized as Super Lawyers – Two Recognized as Rising StarsConstruction May Begin with Documents, but It Shouldn’t End That WayIRMI Expert Commentary: Managing Insurance Coverage from Multiple InsurersNew York Establishes a Registration Requirement for Contractors and Subcontractors Performing Public Works and Covered Private ProjectsGloria Gaynor Sues Contractor over Defective Deck ConstructionLien Attaches To Landlord’s Interest When Landlord Is Party To Tenant Improvement Construction ContractIncorporation, Indemnity and Statutes of Limitations, Oh My!Consult with Counsel when Preparing Construction LiensNewmeyer Dillion Named 2022 Best Law Firm in Multiple Practice Areas By U.S. News-Best LawyersImplications for Industry as Supreme Court Curbs EPA's AuthoritySeveral Lewis Brisbois Partners Recognized by Sacramento Magazine in List of Top LawyersThat Boilerplate Language May Just Land You in Hot WaterAfter Pittsburgh Bridge Collapse, Fast-Rising Replacement EmergesWhat Will the 2024 Construction Economy Look Like?Supply Chain Delay RecommendationsReminder About the Upcoming Mechanic’s Lien Form ChangeContractors Struggle with Cash & Difficult Payment Terms, Could Benefit From Legal Advice, According to New SurveyReservation of Rights Letter Merely Citing Policy Provisions InadequatePreliminary Notices: Common Avoidable But Fatal MistakesDoes a No-Damage-for-Delay Clause Also Preclude Acceleration Damages?Late Notice Bars Insured's Claim for Loss Caused by HurricaneBurden of Proof Under All-Risk Property Insurance Policy The Right to Repair Act (Civ.C §895 et seq.) Applies and is the Exclusive Remedy for a Homeowner Alleging Construction DefectsBOOK CLUB SERIES: Everything You Want to Know About Construction Arbitration But Were Afraid to AskFailure to Timely File Suit in Federal Court for Flood Loss is FatalColorado Construction-Defects Reform Law Attempt Expected in 2015What Lies BeneathIndemnity Clauses—What do they mean, and what should you be looking for?Rio Olympics Work Was a Mess and Then Something Curious HappenedInsured's Motion for Reconsideration on Denial of Coverage UnsuccessfulHouston Home Sales Fall for the First Time in Six MonthsMitigate Construction Risk Through Use of ContingencyIndemnity Provision Provides Relief to Contractor; Additional Insured Provision Does NotConstruction Law Alert: A Specialty License May Not Be Required If Work Covered By Another LicenseTop 10 Take-Aways: the ABA Forum's 2024 Mid-Winter MeetingBad Faith Claim for Inadequate Investigation Does Not Survive Summary JudgmentLewis Brisbois Listed as Top 10 Firm of 2022 on Leopard Solutions Law Firm IndexDeescalating Hyper EscalationLandmark Contractor Licensing Case Limits Disgorgement Remedy in CaliforniaLiving With a Millennial. Or Grandma.Improvements to AIA Contracts?Suffolk Construction Drywall Suits Involve Claim for $3 Million in Court CostsHow California’s Construction Industry has dealt with the New Indemnity LawIs the Construction Industry Actually a Technology Hotbed?When Do Hard-Nosed Negotiations Become Coercion? Or, When Should You Feel Unlucky?2023 West Coast Casualty Construction Defect SeminarReroof Blamed for $10 Million in DamageOrlando Commercial Construction Permits Double in ValueMy Construction Law Wish ListBlockbuster Breakwater: Alternative Construction Method Put to the Test in Tampa BayBuilding Supplier Sued for Late and Defective Building MaterialsDo Construction Contracts and Fraud Mix After All?ALERT: COVID-19 / Coronavirus-Related Ransomware and Phishing Attacks 
