Construction Litigation Roundup: “D’Oh!”
August 12, 2024 —
Daniel Lund III - LexologyThe U.S. DOL found itself on June 24 on the wrong end of a preliminary injunction concerning recent changes to the Davis-Bacon Act.
The lawsuit, initiated in Texas federal court by the Associated General Contractors of America and other concerned citizens, sought a preliminary injunction barring implementation and enforcement of “specified portions of § 5.2 and § 5.5(e) of the DOL’s ‘Updating the Davis-Bacon and Related Acts Regulations’” – the “Final Rule,” published August 23, 2023.
After determining the appropriateness of the “standing” of the plaintiffs based upon the plaintiffs being “adversely affected” by the Final Rule, the federal court preliminarily enjoined enforcement of the Final Rule. In noting its disagreement with the Final Rule, the court stated:
“… the Final Rule amends the DBA [the Davis-Bacon Act] by imposing a stealth selfimplementing DBA requirement in the contract by an operation-of-law provision that contradicts the express statutory language of the Act [the court bristling at the idea that contracts might exclude with impunity the otherwise mandated DBA clauses]. Further, the Final Rule amends the Act to extend the DBA to apply to workers who are not mechanics and laborers, and to extend the scope of the work covered by DBA to include work is not performed ‘directly on the site of the work.’
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Daniel Lund III, PhelpsMr. Lund may be contacted at
daniel.lund@phelps.com
Five Issues to Consider in Government Contracting (Or Any Contracting!)
September 02, 2024 —
David Adelstein - Florida Construction Legal UpdatesThe appeal of Appeals of – Konecranes Nuclear Equipment & Services, LLC, ASBCA 62797, 2024 WL 2698011 (May 7, 2024) raises interesting, but important, issues that should be considered. In this case, the government (in a supply contract) procured four portal cranes from the claimant. After an initial test of one of the cranes failed, the government refused to accept delivery even after the issue was addressed by the claimant. The government did not accept the manner in which the claimant addressed the issue and would only accept cranes if the claimant employed “an unnecessary alternative solution [that] caused further delay and increased [claimant’s] costs.” On appeal, it was determined the government’s decision to delay delivery based on its demand for the alternative solution was not justified, i.e., constituted a breach of contract. Below are five issues of consideration in government contracting, or, for that matter, any contracting.
Issue #1- Patently Ambiguous Specifications
The government argued that the specifications were patently ambiguous and because the claimant failed to inquire regarding the ambiguous specifications prior to performance, its interpretation of the ambiguous specifications should govern. The contractor countered that the specifications were unambiguous and it met the specifications.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
David Adelstein, Kirwin Norris, P.A.Mr. Adelstein may be contacted at
dma@kirwinnorris.com
Payne & Fears Recognized by Best Lawyers in 2025 Best Law Firms®
December 03, 2024 —
Payne & Fears LLPPayne & Fears LLP has been named to the 2025 Best Lawyers “Best Law Firms” list. This recognition highlights firms that demonstrate professional excellence, receiving outstanding ratings from both clients and peers.
Payne & Fears has been ranked in the following practice areas:
Metropolitan Tier 1
- Orange County
- Commercial Litigation
- Employment Law – Management
- Insurance Law
- Labor Law – Management
- Litigation – Labor and Employment
- Litigation – Real Estate
Metropolitan Tier 2
Metropolitan Tier 3
- Orange County
- Litigation – Intellectual Property
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Payne & Fears LLP
GRSM Attorneys Selected to 2024 Super Lawyers and Rising Stars Lists
January 14, 2025 —
Gordon Rees Scully MansukhaniSuper Lawyers® has released its 2024 attorney lists across various regions of the United States. This year, 169 Gordon Rees Scully Mansukhani attorneys have been selected, with 51 named to Super Lawyers and 118 named to Rising Stars.
*For attorneys licensed to practice in New Jersey: No aspect of this advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court of New Jersey. Please visit the Super Lawyers Selection Process for a detailed description of the Super Lawyers and Rising Stars selection methodology.
The selections are a result of independent research by the team at Super Lawyers® to determine no more than the top five percent of legal professionals in each geographic region. The research team selects no more than two and a half percent of the lawyers in each geographic region to the Rising Stars list.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Gordon Rees Scully Mansukhani
With Wildfires at a Peak, “Firetech” Is Joining Smart City Lineups
October 21, 2024 —
James P. Bobotek - Gravel2Gavel Construction & Real Estate Law BlogThe
threat of extreme wildfires has doubled in the past 20 years, with almost 20,000 fires blazing across the United States in 2024 alone. These high-intensity fires can be deadly, expensive, and create lingering health and environmental consequences. While we are used to seeing firefighters on the frontlines, researchers hope that next-generation smart technology, augmented by artificial intelligence (AI), will also play a key role in battling these conflagrations. Many municipalities, particularly those near wildfire-prone forests, are beginning to incorporate fire-focused advances (or “firetech”) into their smart city ecosystems.
“Smart cities” are urban centers enhanced by utilities, emergency services,
traffic signals and more that are linked through information and communications technology. Though the concept can spark cybersecurity-related concerns, many locales are gradually implementing many different kinds of smart tech. Following the 2023 wildfire that devastated Maui, for example, Hawaii installed a network of
cloud-based fire and wind sensors that use AI to detect wildfires in real time. Smart tools like these can aid in predicting and discovering fires, streamlining emergency alert protocols, calculating vital analytics and improving firefighter safety. The National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) is
actively studying these innovations, particularly in terms of environmental (smart buildings or robotics), operational (communications) and personnel (PPE sensors or biometrics). Below are a few of the key technologies to watch in this emerging field:
- Smart Sensors. A total of 80 sensors (64 wildfire sensors and 16 wind sensors) were placed throughout Hawaii starting in March of 2024. Attached to existing utility poles, they detect heat in the air, and then engage AI and smart learning to distinguish smoke particles and gases produced by fires from those commonly found in Hawaii’s atmosphere—such as volcanic ash and ocean salt. Positioned in “strings,” the sensors “talk” to each other and send text messages to officials when they find a problem.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
James P. Bobotek, PillsburyMr. Bobotek may be contacted at
james.bobotek@pillsburylaw.com
A Funny Thing Happened to My Ground Lease in Bankruptcy Court
November 25, 2024 —
Christopher F. Graham & Morgan A. Goldstein - White and Williams LLPEXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Ground leases are an important – if somewhat unusual – part of the real estate finance industry. Because they typically cover large expensive properties like Rockefeller Center and The Empire State Building, to name two, and last a long time (99 years and up to start) the likelihood of something unexpected or unintended happening is high. This likelihood increases dramatically if, as highlighted below, one or both of the lease parties’ files for bankruptcy. Accordingly, real estate professionals should take note and take care when entering into any transaction involving a ground lease.
Reprinted courtesy of
Christopher F. Graham, White and Williams LLP and
Morgan A. Goldstein, White and Williams LLP
Mr. Graham may be contacted at grahamc@whiteandwilliams.com
Ms. Goldstein may be contacted at goldsteinm@whiteandwilliams.com
Read the full story...
“Since You Asked. . .”
October 15, 2024 —
Daniel Lund III - Lexology… you must now pay.
So said a California appellate court, affirming the trial court’s decision against a subcontractor suing for unpaid subcontract sums. Instead of being awarded those unpaid amounts, the subcontractor lost the case and was tagged with a $1.55 million attorney’s fees award and $270,000 costs award in favor of the defendants.
What went wrong?
California law requires a licensed contractor to maintain at all times proper workers’ compensation insurance coverage. The failure to maintain the coverage and have the certificate of coverage on file with the California Contractors State License Board results in “automatic and immediate suspension” of the contractor license. Retroactive reinstatement of the license may occur only if the contractor provides proof of the insurance within 90 days of the effective date of the insurance certificate – unless the contractor can show that failure to have the certificate on file was “due to circumstances beyond the control of the licensee.”
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Daniel Lund III, PhelpsMr. Lund may be contacted at
daniel.lund@phelps.com
Insured Fails to Provide Adequate Proof of Water Damage Through Roof
December 10, 2024 —
Tred R. Eyerly - Insurance Law HawaiiThe federal district court granted the insurer's motion for summary judgment due on the insured's claims for water damage to a church. Unity Church of God in Christ of York v. Church Mutual Ins. Co., 2024 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 163204 (M.D. Pa. Sept. 11, 2024).
Unity Church alleged that it suffered a sudden and accidental direct physical loss to its church. Wind damag
Demanding a Reduction in RetainageNot So Fast, My Friend: Pacing and Concurrent DelayIf You Don’t Like the PPP Now, Wait a Few Minutes…Major Changes to PPP Loan Program as Congress Passes Payroll Protection Program Flexibility ActU.S. Building Permits Soared to Their Highest Level in Nearly Eight YearsNo Rest for the Weary: Project Completion Is the Beginning of LitigationN.J. Governor Signs Bill Expanding P3s The Court-Side Seat: FERC Reviews, Panda Power Plaints and Sovereign ImmunityA Quick Checklist for SubcontractorsARUP, Rethinking Green InfrastructureCGL Coverage Dispute Regarding the (J)(6) And (J)(7) Property Damage ExclusionsSubcontractors Eye 2022 with Guarded OptimismGeorgia Court of Appeals Holds Lay Witness Can Provide Opinion Testimony on the Value of a Property If the Witness Had an Opportunity to Form a Reasoned OpinionSubcontractor's Faulty Workmanship Is Not an "Occurrence"Two New Developments in Sanatoga, PennsylvaniaInsurance Litigation Roundup: “Post No Bills!”Kahana Feld Partner Noelle Natoli Named President of Women Lawyers Association of Los AngelesConstruction Litigation Roundup: “That’s Not How I Read It”Sources of Insurance Recovery for Emerging PFAS ClaimsContractors with Ties to Trustees Reaped Benefits from LA Community College Modernization ProgramNew Case Alert: California Federal Court Allows Policy Stacking to Cover Continuous InjuryModernist Houses Galore! [visual candy for architects]Texas School System Goes to Court over Construction DefectPredicting the Future of Texas’s Grid Is a Texas-Sized ChallengeBest U.S. Home Sales Since 2007 Show Momentum in Housing MarketApartments pushed up US homebuilding in SeptemberContractor May Be Barred Until Construction Lawsuit SettledEffective Strategies for Reinforcing Safety Into Evolving Design StandardsIncrease in Single-Family New Home Sales Year-Over-Year in JanuaryClient Alert: Release of Liability Agreement Extinguishes Duty of Ordinary CareDaniel Ferhat Receives Two Awards for Service to the Legal CommunityInsurer Must Defend Additional Insured Though Its Insured is a Non-PartyMexico's Richest Man Carlos Slim to Rebuild Collapsed Subway LineIllinois Court Determines Duty to Defend Construction Defect ClaimsRepairs Commencing on Defect-Ridden House from Failed State Supreme Court CaseVideo: Contractors’ Update on New Regulations Governing Commercial Use of DronesRecent Developments with California’s Right to Repair ActFirm Leadership – New Co-Chairs for the Construction Law Practice GroupSoldiers Turn Brickies as U.K. Homebuilders Seek WorkersIs it the Dawning of the Age of Strict Products Liability for Contractors in California?Ten ACS Lawyers Recognized as Super Lawyers or Rising StarsCongratulations to Partner Madeline Arcellana on Her Selection as a Top Rank Attorney in Nevada!Reminder About the Upcoming Mechanic’s Lien Form ChangeThe Problem with One Year WarrantiesMontana Supreme Court Tackles Decade-Old Coverage Dispute Concerning Asbestos Mineworker ClaimsNew Plan Submitted for Explosive Demolition of Old Tappan Zee BridgeSuper Lawyers Selects Haight Lawyers for Its 2024 Southern California Rising Stars ListSanibel Causeway Repair: Contractors Flooded Site With Crews, ResourcesBank Window Lawsuit Settles QuietlyReal Estate & Construction News Roundup (06/28/23) – Combating Homelessness, U.S. Public Transportation Costs and the Future of Commercial Real EstateAlabama Appeals Court Rules Unexpected and Unintended Property Damage is an OccurrenceOne-Upmanship by Contractors In Prevailing Wage Decision Leads to a Bad Result for All . . . PerhapsBrown Act Modifications in Response to Coronavirus OutbreakBalfour in Talks With Carillion About $5 Billion MergerRound and Round: Inside the Las Vegas SphereWhere Breach of Contract and Tortious Interference CollideWater Leak Covered for First Thirteen DaysTests Find Pollution From N.C. Coal Ash Site Hit by Florence Within Acceptable Levelstruction Automation – Discussion with Aviad Almagor
Is Your Website Accessible And Are You Liable If It Isn't?Construction Defect Litigation at San Diego’s Alicante Condominiums?Construction Defect Bill a Long Shot in Nevada25 Days After Explosion, Another Utility Shuts Off Gas in Boston Area 
