Rhode Island Closes One Bridge and May Have Burned Others with Ensuing Lawsuit
October 07, 2024 —
Bill Wilson - Construction Law ZoneThe state of Rhode Island recently filed a lawsuit against 13 companies that provided design, construction, and inspection services over the past ten years (the extent allowed by the applicable statute of limitations) to the Washington Bridge, which carries I-195 between East Providence and Providence. The bridge was abruptly closed in December 2023 following the discovery of alleged fractured steel tie-downs critical to the bridge’s stability and additional deterioration in cantilever beams throughout the bridge. Before the closure, approximately 90,000 vehicles per day traveled over the bridge.
The complaint alleges that the defendants, the majority of which are experienced, industry-leading firms in their respective fields, were negligent and breached their respective contracts with the State. The State contends that every company that worked on the bridge over the past ten years missed the serious structural conditions alleged. The lawsuit also claims that the State has suffered millions of dollars of damages since the bridge was closed and seeks indemnity and contribution from all defendants to the extent that the State may be liable to third parties in the future.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Bill Wilson, Robinson & Cole LLP
More (and Simpler) Options Under New Oregon Retention Law
October 21, 2024 —
Michael Yelle - Ahlers Cressman & Sleight PLLCSimilar to the changes made by the Washington Legislature last year, the Oregon Legislature recently changed its retention law. Oregon public works agencies and large commercial project owners are now required to accept surety bonds in lieu of withholding retainage on construction projects. There is also no longer a requirement to deposit retention funds in an interest-bearing escrow account.
The owner or public agency must accept the bond in lieu of retainage unless specific grounds exist. For example, public agencies must find there is “good cause” for rejection of the bond based on the “unique project circumstances. Private owners have less discretion to reject a bond and if the bond meets the statutory requirements, per ORS 701.435(1)(a) “the owner and lender shall accept” the bond “in lieu of all or any portion of the retainage…”
Courts have not analyzed when “good cause” exists for public agencies to reject bonds or exactly what will allow a private owner to reject a bond. However, an agency or owner cannot have a general policy to reject retention bonds. The statute does not provide next steps if the contractor disagrees with a decision to reject the bond. It may be necessary to proceed under the contract’s dispute resolution procedure or it may be more appropriate to take the issue directly to the courts.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Michael Yelle, Ahlers Cressman & Sleight PLLCMr. Yelle may be contacted at
michael.yelle@acslawyers.com
Key Legal Issues to Consider Before and After Natural Disasters
November 25, 2024 —
Patrick Kelly - Construction ExecutiveWhile legal considerations are often the last thing on the minds of project owners and contractors during an emergency, construction industry stakeholders should bear in mind the impact of natural disasters on their legal rights, remedies and potential exposure to claims.
For all stakeholders, two of the most pressing considerations are: (1) what provisions in their contracts are impacted by a natural disaster and (2) do they have any potential exposure to price-gouging claims?
Reprinted courtesy of
Patrick Kelly, Construction Executive, a publication of Associated Builders and Contractors. All rights reserved.
Read the full story...Mr. Kelly may be contacted at
pkelly@grayreed.com
Edison Utility Accused of Igniting LA Fire in Lawsuits
January 21, 2025 —
Jef Feeley, Mark Chediak & Malathi Nayak - BloombergEdison International Inc.’s southern California utility faces lawsuits blaming the energy provider’s equipment for igniting one of the wildfires still raging in the second-largest US metropolis.
The first of several suits filed Monday was brought on behalf of a group of homeowners, renters, business owners and others with properties destroyed by the deadly Eaton Fire in the Pasadena area. The complaints allege that Southern California Edison power lines were the cause of the blaze that leveled the community of Altadena. The initial suits are expected to be followed by thousands more legal claims.
Reprinted courtesy of
Jef Feeley, Bloomberg,
Mark Chediak, Bloomberg and
Malathi Nayak, Bloomberg Read the full story...
Climate Disasters Are an Affordable Housing Problem
October 01, 2024 —
Juan Pablo Garnham & Arjuna Heim - BloombergWhen Maui was devastated by wildfires in August 2023, some residents were initially fortunate. The neighborhood of Makawao, for example, was spared the worst effects of the fire that engulfed Lahaina, 35 miles to the west.
Recently, though, we met a woman in that neighborhood who faces a different kind of threat: Her landlord has now demanded that she pay double her rent or face eviction. As housing advocates in the region, we’ve heard stories like this repeatedly, as residents report an acute fear of displacement and homelessness.
A year after the fires killed more than 100 people, displaced 12,000 and disrupted the economy of the island, the disaster lingers for many in Maui and Hawai'i. Rents across the island have increased sharply, offering a cautionary tale for the rest of the US about how climate change, a housing crisis and the lack of adequate public policies can multiply the suffering of a community already in pain.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Bloomberg
Courthouse Reporter Series: Louisiana Supreme Court Holds Architect Has No Duty to Safeguard Third Parties Against Injury, Regardless of Knowledge of Dangerous Conditions on the Project
July 31, 2024 —
Stu Richeson - The Dispute ResolverIn Bonilla v. Verges Rome Architects, 2023-00928 (La. 3/22/24); 382 So.3d 62, the Louisiana Supreme Court held because the terms of the agreement between the architect and the public owner did not give the architect responsibility for the means and methods of construction or for safety on the project, the architect did not have a duty to safeguard third parties against injury, regardless of whether the architect may have had knowledge of dangerous conditions on the project.
In Bonilla, the City of New Orleans entered into a contract for the renovation of a building owned by the city. The city also entered into an agreement with Verges Rome Architects (“VRA”) to serve as the project architect. The general contractor on the project subcontracted the demolition work to Meza Services, Inc. (“Meza”).
An employee of Meza was injured while attempting to demolish a “vault” on the project. The vault was a ten-foot by ten-foot cinderblock room with a nine-foot-high concrete slab ceiling located on the second floor of the building. The walls of the vault had been partially demolished when one of the employees of Meza was directed by his supervisor to stand on the ceiling of the vault with a jackhammer to continue the demolition. Shortly after beginning the task, the vault structure collapsed and caused the employee to suffer significant injury.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Stu Richeson, PhelpsMr. Richeson may be contacted at
stuart.richeson@phelps.com
Scott Saylin Expands Employment Litigation and Insurance Litigation Team at Payne & Fears
September 23, 2024 —
Payne & Fears LLPScott Saylin has joined Payne & Fears LLP as a Law Clerk in the firm’s Employment Litigation Group and Insurance Litigation Group. Before his time at Payne & Fears, Scott served as a law clerk for Cascadia Healthcare in Boise, Idaho.
“We are pleased to welcome Scott Saylin back to the firm. He was with us as a summer associate before completing his final year of law school at George Washington University,” said Amy Patton, the group’s co-chair. “Scott has fantastic potential to develop into an excellent litigator and will be an asset to our team.”
Get to Know Scott
What activities do you enjoy outside of work?
Pickle ball, long walks, beach trips, cooking, watching the Lakers games, and playing the guitar & piano.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Payne & Fears LLP
Congratulations to Las Vegas Partner Jeffrey W. Saab and Associate Shanna B. Carter on Obtaining Another Defense Award at Arbitration!
January 14, 2025 —
Dolores Montoya - Bremer Whyte Brown & O'Meara LLPThe case arose from an incident at Plaintiff’s residence where she alleged that a failure to properly diagnose an issue with her HVAC unit led to its destruction, displacement from her home, and damage to her roof and kitchen, resulting in a diminution of value to her house. Jeff and Shanna represented the HVAC contractor, who denied any wrongdoing during the two-day arbitration at which a total of six witnesses were examined. Jeff and Shanna utilized Plaintiff’s own experts’ testimony to successfully challenge liability and bring forth a motion for spoliation, resulting in a complete defense award for Jeff and Shanna’s client, which included an award of costs.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Dolores Montoya, Bremer Whyte Brown & O'Meara LLPNYC Rail Tunnel Cost Jumps and Construction Start Pushed BackWhat ENR.com Construction News Gained the Most ViewsNew York Court Permits Asbestos Claimants to Proceed Against Insurers with Buyout AgreementsNew York High Court: “Issued or Delivered” Includes Policies Insuring Risks in New YorkCoverage for Construction Defects Barred by Business Risk ExclusionsVirginia Civil Engineers Give the State's Infrastructure a "C" GradeNo Coverage for Faulty Workmanship Where Underlying Claim is Strictly Breach of ContractTrends: “Nearshoring” Opportunities for the Construction IndustryDuuers: Better Proposals with Less WorkFifth Circuit Holds Insurer Owes Duty to Defend Latent Condition Claim That Caused Fire Damage to Property Years After Construction WorkNAHB Examines Single-Family Detached Concentration StatisticsDigital Twins – Interview with Cristina SavianClaims for Negligence? Duty to Defend TriggeredEEOC Chair Issues New Report “Building for the Future: Advancing Equal Employment Opportunity in the Construction Industry”Empire State Building Owners Sue Photographer for Topless Photo ShootImpaired Property Exclusion Bars Coverage When Loose Bolt Interferes with MRI Unit OperationEleven Newmeyer Dillion Attorneys Named to 2023 U.S. News Best Lawyers in Multiple Practice AreasHomebuilding on the Rise in Nation’s CapitolCourt Dismisses Coverage Action In Lieu of Pending State CaseContractor May Be Barred Until Construction Lawsuit SettledFannie Mae, Freddie Mac Shares Fall on Wind-Down MeasureMBIA Seeks Data in $1 Billion Credit Suisse Mortgage SuitSkipping Depositions does not Constitute Failure to Cooperate in New YorkDenver Court Rules that Condo Owners Must Follow Arbitration AgreementHiring Subcontractors with Workers Compensation InsuranceColorado Legislative Update: HB 20-1155, HB 20-1290, and HB 20-1348Texas Windstorm Insurance Agency Under ScrutinyCreeping Incrementalism in Downstream Insurance: Carriers are Stretching Standard CGL Concepts to Untenable LimitsDigitalizing Cross-Laminated Timber ConstructionJet Crash Blamed on Runway Construction DefectAlabama Limits Duty to Defend for Construction DefectsQuick Note: Steps to Protect and Avoid the “Misappropriation” of a “Trade Secret”ConsensusDOCS Updates its FormsTexas Jury Awards $5.3 Million to Company Defamed by Union: Could it work in Pennsylvania?New York Developers Facing Construction Defect LawsuitRevisiting OSHA’s Controlling Employer PolicyInsurer's Motion to Dismiss Business Interruption, COVID-19 Claims Under Pollution Policy FailsIllinois Insureds are Contesting One Carrier's Universal Denial to Covid-19 LossesConstruction Law: Unexpected, Fascinating, BizarreReal Estate & Construction News Roundup (6/26/24) – Construction Growth in Office and Data Center Sectors, Slight Ease in Consumer Price Index and Increased Premiums for Commercial BuildingsJason Smith and Teddie Arnold Co-Author Updated “United States – Construction” Chapter in 2024 Legal 500: Country Comparative GuidesResurgent Housing Seen Cushioning U.S. From World Woes: EconomyGordon & Rees Ranked #4 of Top 50 Construction Law Firms in the Nation by Construction Executive MagazineJudge Sentences Roofing Contractor Owner in Florida PPP Fraud CaseLucky No. 7: Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals Issues Pro-Policyholder Decision Regarding Additional Insured Coverage for Upstream PartiesSubcontractors Essential to Home Building IndustryCourt of Federal Claims: Upstream Hurricane Harvey Case Will Proceed to TrialWildfire Smoke Threatens to Wipe Out Decades of Air Pollution ProgressWisconsin Supreme Court Abandons "Integrated Systems Analysis" for Determining Property DamageManhattan Townhouse Sells for a Record $79.5 Million 
