First Circuit Rejects Insurer’s “Insupportable” Duty-to-Cooperate Defense in Arson Coverage Suit
October 24, 2023 —
Geoffrey B. Fehling & Yaniel Abreu - Hunton Insurance Recovery BlogIn
Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Co. v. BAS Holding Corp., the Court of Appeals for the First Circuit rejected an insurer’s “insupportable” defense that the insured company had breached its duty to cooperate by refusing the insurer’s request for an examination under oath of the company’s president. The decision is a reminder that, while examinations under oath can be effective tools to allow the insurer to properly investigate a claim, an insured’s duty to cooperate is not boundless and does not demand attendance at examinations that are not reasonably requested.
Background
BAS Holding involves the destruction of a landmark building in Boston by an arsonist. The owner, BAS Holding Corporation, submitted an insurance claim to its property insurer to recover insurance proceeds for the damage to the building. The insurer investigated the claim to determine whether the damage to the building was covered and issued a reservation of rights letter suggesting that the policy may not provide coverage for the fire. As part of its investigation, the insurer requested an examination under oath as a condition to coverage under the policy, which led to BAS presenting the property’s operations coordinator for an interview. Shortly after examining the operations coordinator, the insurer sought another examination of BAS’s president and owner, as well as five other employees. In response, BAS questioned whether the additional examinations were “reasonably required” and said that it would consider the requests if the insurer could explain why they were necessary.
Reprinted courtesy of
Geoffrey B. Fehling, Hunton Andrews Kurth and
Yaniel Abreu, Hunton Andrews Kurth
Mr. Fehling may be contacted at gfehling@HuntonAK.com
Mr. Abreu may be contacted at yabreu@HuntonAK.com
Read the full story...
New Jersey Strengthens the Structural Integrity of Its Residential Builds
March 11, 2024 —
Matthew D. Stockwell - Gravel2Gavel Construction & Real Estate Law BlogIn response to the June 2021 Champlain Towers collapse in Florida, New Jersey supplemented its State Uniform Construction Code Act by enacting legislation (effective January 8, 2024) to strengthen laws related to the structural integrity of certain residential structures in the State. The legislation applies to condominiums and cooperatives (but not single-family dwellings or primarily rental buildings) with structural components made of steel, reinforced concrete, heavy timber or a combination of such materials. The legislation also supplements the Planned Real Estate Development Full Disclosure Act to ensure that associations created under the Act maintain adequate reserve funds for certain repairs.
The legislation requires structural engineering inspections of any primary load-bearing system (structural components applying force to the building which deliver force to the ground including any connected balconies). Buildings that are constructed after the date the legislation was signed must have their first inspection within 15 years after receiving a Certificate of Occupancy. Buildings that are 15 years or older must be inspected within two years of the legislation. Thereafter, the structural inspector will determine when the next inspection should take place, which will be no more than 10 years after the preceding inspection, except for buildings more than 20 years old which must be inspected every five years. Also, if damage to the primary load-bearing system is otherwise observable, an inspection must be performed within 60 days.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Matthew D. Stockwell, PillsburyMr. Stockwell may be contacted at
matthew.stockwell@pillsburylaw.com
Empowering Success: The Advantages of Female Attorneys in Construction Defect Law
December 11, 2023 —
Alexa Stephenson, Hoosai Kabiri & Ivette Kincaid - Kahana FeldPer the most recent U.S. Census records, women make up 50.4% of the U.S. population. It should come as no surprise then that women currently outnumber men in U.S. law schools. Nevertheless, as of 2022, only 38% of attorneys, 30% of federal judges, 22% of equity partners, and 12% of managing partners nationwide are comprised of women. While great strides have been made in the last century to increase gender equality in the legal field, there is undoubtedly still a long way to go.
Studies have shown that women in the workforce lead to a number of benefits not only to the business itself, but to a business’ employees and culture. In the realm of construction defect law in particular, the presence and contributions of female attorneys have become increasingly impactful and essential. As the legal landscape evolves, the benefits of having female attorneys practicing in this specialized field are becoming more evident, offering a range of advantages that contribute to a more diverse, comprehensive, and successful legal environment. These advantages include:
1. Diverse Perspectives: Female attorneys bring a unique perspective to the practice of construction defect law, enriching the field with their insights and experiences. Their diverse backgrounds and viewpoints can lead to innovative strategies and fresh approaches when tackling complex legal issues.
Reprinted courtesy of
Alexa Stephenson, Kahana Feld,
Hoosai Kabiri, Kahana Feld and
Ivette Kincaid, Kahana Feld
Ms. Stephenson may be contacted at astephenson@kahanafeld.com
Ms. Kabiri may be contacted at hkabiri@kahanafeld.com
Ms. Kincaid may be contacted at ikincaid@kahanafeld.com
Read the full story...
Construction Litigation Roundup: “Wrap Music to an Insurer’s Ears?”
February 05, 2024 —
Daniel Lund III - LexologyThe general contractor on a New Orleans condominium construction project obtained a Contractor Controlled Insurance Program/CCIP policy or "Wrap-Up" policy for the job.
An accident occurred on the job when a construction elevator/hoist fell, injuring several workers. The elevator/hoist was provided by a subcontractor, pursuant to a rental agreement and related subcontract with the general contractor. Contained within the subcontract was a provision which states that the general contractor "has arranged for the Project to be insured under a controlled insurance program (the "CCIP" or "WrapUp"),” and that the CCIP shall provide "commercial general liability insurance and excess liability insurance, in connection with the performance of the Work at the Project site."
A third-party administrator for the wrap-up policy had been in communication with the subcontractor prior to the commencement of the work, “specifically advising that insurance coverage was not automatic” and providing the subcontractor with an enrollment form for the CCIP. Ultimately, the subcontractor “declined to comply with the request,” stating that the subcontractor would "not participate in paying any wrap insurance premiums" – because the subcontractor had its own insurance.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Daniel Lund III, PhelpsMr. Lund may be contacted at
daniel.lund@phelps.com
GOP, States, Industry Challenge EPA Project Water Impact Rule
January 02, 2024 —
Pam McFarland - Engineering News-RecordDays after the Biden administration rule reinstated state authority under the U.S. Clean Water Act to delay or deny construction permits on projects with water quality impacts, attorneys general from 11 Republican-led states, along with the American Petroleum Association, National Hydropower Association and Interstate Natural Gas Association of America, filed suit in federal court.
Reprinted courtesy of
Pam McFarland, Engineering News-Record
Ms. McFarland may be contacted at mcfarlandp@enr.com
Read the full story...
Payne & Fears LLP Recognized by Best Lawyers in 2024 “Best Law Firms” Rankings
November 27, 2023 —
Payne & Fears LLPPayne & Fears LLP has been recognized by Best Lawyers 2024 “Best Law Firms” list. Firms included in the 2024 edition of Best Lawyers “Best Law Firms” are recognized for professional excellence with consistently impressive ratings from clients and peers.
Payne & Fears LLP has been ranked in the following practice areas:
- Metropolitan Tier 1
- Orange County
- Commercial Litigation
- Employment Law – Management
- Insurance Law
- Labor Law – Management
- Litigation – Labor & Employment
- Litigation – Real Estate
- Metropolitan Tier 3
- Orange County
- Litigation – Intellectual Property
Read the full story...
Federal Magistrate Judge Recommends Rescission of Policies
February 12, 2024 —
Craig Rokuson - Traub LiebermanIn the recent case of Union Mut. Fire Ins. Co. v. 142 Driggs LLC, 2023 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 220393, Magistrate Judge Lois Bloom of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York recommended granting the insurer's default judgment and holding that of three policies issued to 142 Driggs
20 Years of BHA at West Coast Casualty's CD Seminar: Chronicling BHA's Innovative Exhibits“Rip and Tear” Damage Remains Covered Under CGL Policy as “Accident”—for Now.Cal/OSHA ETS: Newest Version Effective TodayColorado SB 15-177 UPDATE: Senate Business, Labor, & Technology Committee Refers Construction Defect Reform Bill to Full SenateProviding “Labor” Under the Miller ActFive Facts About Housing That Will Make People In New York City and San Francisco DepressedSan Diego County Considering Updates to Green Building CodeInsurer Must Defend Where Possible Continuing Property Damage OccurredSuffolk Stands Down After Consecutive Serious Boston Site InjuriesMass. Gas Leak Follows NTSB Final Report, Call for ReformsSick Leave, Paid Time Off, and the Families First Coronavirus Response Act Is It Time to Digitize Safety?Traub Lieberman Attorneys Jessica Burtnett and Jessica Kull Obtain Dismissal of Claim Against Insurance Producer Based Upon Statute of LimitationsEye on Housing Examines Costs of Green FeaturesRelease Language Extended To Successor Entity But Only Covered “Known” ClaimsDecades of WCC Seminar at the Disneyland ResortCoverage Found for Faulty Workmanship Damaging Other PropertyCourt Holds That One-Year SOL Applies to Disgorgement Claims Under B&P Section 7031How the New Dropped Object Standard Is Changing Jobsite SafetyTariffs, Supply Snarls Spur Search for Factories Closer to U.S.The Value of Photographic Evidence in Construction LitigationBig Builder’s Analysis of the Top Ten Richest CountiesTurner Co
Pay-if-Paid Clauses, Nasty, but Enforceable
Partners Patti Santelle and Gale White honored by as "Top Women in Law" The Legal Intelligencer
Good News on Prices for Some Construction Materials
Quick Note: Aim to Avoid a Stay to your Miller Act Payment Bond Claim
Dusseldorf Evacuates About 4,000 as World War II Bomb Defused
CA Supreme Court: Right to Repair Act (SB 800) is the Exclusive Remedy for Residential Construction Defect Claims – So Now What?
New Mexico Architect Is Tuned Into His State
“Unwinnable”: Newark Trial Team Obtains Unanimous “No Cause” Verdict in Challenging Matter on Behalf of NYC Mutual Housing Association
Billionaire Row Condo Board Sues Developers Over 1,500 Building Defects
Anthony Luckie Speaks With Columbia University On Receiving Graduate Degree in Construction Administration Alongside His Father
Western Specialty Contractors Branches in San Francisco and Cleveland Take Home Top Industry Honors
Connecticut Appellate Court Breaks New Ground on Policy Exhaustion
Columbus, Ohio’s Tallest Building to be Inspected for Construction Defects
Mercury News Editorial Calls for Investigation of Bay Bridge Construction
Top 10 Take-Aways: the ABA Forum's 2024 Mid-Winter Meeting
House of the Week: Spanish Dream Home on California's Riviera
Homebuilders Go Green in Response to Homebuyer Demand
Insolvency of Primary Carrier Does Not Invoke Excess Coverage
Be a Good Neighbor: Techniques to Mitigate the Risk of Claims from Adjacent Landowners
Avoiding Project Planning Disasters: How to Spot Problem Projects
Colorado’s Federal District Court Finds Carriers Have Joint and Several Defense Duties
Billionaire Behind Victoria’s Secret Built His Version of the American Heartland
The Living Makes Buildings Better with Computational Design
Coverage Article - To Settle or Not To Settle?
Town Concerned Over Sinkhole at Condo Complex
Latest Updates On The Coronavirus Pandemic
4 Lessons Contractors Can Learn From The COVID-19 Crisis
Prevailing Parties Entitled to Contractual Attorneys’ Fees Under California CCP §1717 Notwithstanding Declaration That Contract is Void Under California Government Code §1090
Ambitious Building Plans in Boston
Biggest U.S. Gas Leak Followed Years of Problems, State Says
Courthouse Reporter Series: The Travails of Statutory Construction...Defining “Labor” under the Miller Act
Stick to Your Guns on Price and Pricing with Construction Contracts
Corps Spells Out Billions in Infrastructure Act Allocations
Tidal Lagoon Plans Marine Project to Power Every Home in Wales
Bidders Shortlisted as Oroville Dam Work Schedule is Set
Court Holds That Trimming of Neighbor’s Trees is Not an Insured Accident or Occurrence
Federal Magistrate Judge Recommends Rescission of Policies
Nation’s Top Court Limits EPA's Authority in Clean Air Case
Citigroup Reaches $1.13 Billion Pact Over Mortgage Bonds
White Collar Overtime Regulations Temporarily Blocked
Growing Optimism Among Home Builders
2023 Executive Insights From Leaders in Construction Law
Useful Life: A Valuable Theory for Reducing Damages
Recent Florida Legislative Changes Shorten Both Statute of Limitation ("SOL") and Statute of Repose ("SOR") for Construction Defect Claims
Real Estate & Construction News Roundup (2/21/24) – Fed Chair Predicts More Small Bank Closures, Shopping Center Vacancies Hit 15-year Low, and Proptech Sees Mixed Results
New Recommendations for Healthy and Safe Housing Conditions
Hunton Insurance Partner Among Top 250 Women in Litigation
The Dog Ate My Exclusion! – Georgia Federal Court: No Reformation to Add Pollution Exclusion
Arkansas Federal Court Fans the Product Liability Flames Utilizing the Malfunction Theory
Harmon Towers Duty to Defend Question Must Wait, Says Court